The Top 5 Used Sportscars for Sale in 2025 (Budget-Minded Edition)
Shopping the 2025 market for an affordable performance machine can feel like treasure-hunting in a sea of used cars. Inventories fluctuate, asking prices spike on “instant-classic” models, and some listings hide deferred maintenance that turns bargain buys into money pits. To make your search easier, we ranked the five used sportscars that deliver the best mix of reliability, value, and real-world thrills—complete with the horsepower and torque stats gearheads crave.
How We Chose the Winners
- Total ownership cost. We focused on 2018-2021 model-years with proven reliability records and average listing prices under $40 k.
- Performance per dollar. A satisfying power-to-weight ratio mattered more than headline top-speed numbers.
- Daily-driver livability. Good ergonomics, acceptable fuel economy, and reasonable parts prices all scored points.
1. Mazda MX-5 Miata (2019-2021)
Why it tops the list: Lightweight agility, rock-solid reliability, and the lowest buy-in of any modern rear-drive roadster.
Spec Figure
Horsepower / Torque 181 hp / 151 lb-ft
Typical 2025 asking price $15k–$24k, depending on trim and mileage
Budget-friendly angle: Even Grand Touring trims with Bose audio and heated leather seats regularly list below $25k. Insurance is low, parts are abundant, and the 2.0-liter four-cylinder sips premium at nearly 30 mpg combined.
Who will love it: Weekend autocrossers and commuters who crave top-down fun without supercar bills.
2. Subaru BRZ / Toyota 86 (2018-2020)
Why it makes the cut: A perfectly balanced chassis, usable 2+2 seating, and cult-favorite handling.
Spec Figure
Horsepower / Torque 205 hp / 156 lb-ft (manual)
Typical 2025 asking price $23k–$27k for well-kept Limited trims
Budget-friendly angle: The naturally aspirated flat-four keeps maintenance simple, and used examples often carry tasteful suspension or wheel upgrades that add value at no extra cost.
Who will love it: Drivers who prize steering feel over raw straight-line grunt—and parents who need occasional rear-seat space for smaller kids.
3. Ford Mustang GT (2018-2020, S550)
Why it makes the cut: 460 hp of V-8 thunder, endless aftermarket support, and surprising fuel economy on the highway.
Spec Figure
Horsepower / Torque 460 hp / 420 lb-ft
Typical 2025 asking price $24k–$36k for clean GT Premium coupes
Budget-friendly angle: Depreciation is your friend—GTs that stickered for $42k five years ago now trade for the mid-$20ks. Stick with cars that have full service records and avoid heavily modified drag-strip specials to protect resale value.
Who will love it: Anyone who believes every great American road trip should be narrated by a 5.0-liter soundtrack.
4. Chevrolet Camaro SS (2019-2021)
Why it makes the cut: Track-ready chassis tuning, Brembo brakes, and the muscular LT1 V-8—all for less cash than a comparable pony-car rival.
Spec Figure
Horsepower / Torque 455 hp / 455 lb-ft
Typical 2025 asking price About $40k for low-mile SS models; mid-$20 ks for higher-mile 1SS coupes
Budget-friendly angle: The SS offers magnetic-ride dampers and a six-piston Brembo upgrade rarely found at this price point. Just note that the low roof and small windows limit outward visibility—test drive before you commit.
Who will love it: Performance bargain hunters who value skid-pad grip and quarter-mile times over rear-seat practicality.
5. Nissan 370Z (2018-2020)
Why it makes the cut: Old-school analog feel, bulletproof 3.7-liter V-6, and rising collectability as the last “pure” Z before the turbo-charged 400-hp successor.
Spec Figure
Horsepower / Torque 332 hp / 270 lb-ft (base)
Typical 2025 asking price $17k–$32k, with NISMO versions topping $40 k
Budget-friendly angle: Base trims under $25k deliver the same engine as pricier Sport models. Look for pristine 50th-Anniversary Editions if you want future-classic potential without breaking the bank.
Who will love it: Drivers who miss hydraulic steering feel, manual gearboxes, and the soundtrack of a free-revving V-6.
Drive Away With Confidence
Monster Motors makes every upgrade smooth and rewarding. Start with an instant, no-obligation trade-in valuation through our online appraisal tool, then rely on our certified truck specialists to turn that offer into the best deal possible.
Backed by real-time market data and transparent pricing, you’ll know exactly what your current truck is worth before you arrive. With convenient locations in Michigan and Tennessee, you can finalize your offer, compare models side by side, and drive home in a newer, tougher, or more luxurious truck the same day.
Visit Monster Motors online or stop by in person and experience why drivers across the region trust us to deliver the top trade-in values of 2025.
